Looking for what the psychoanalytic tripod is and how it works in training today? See the guide Psychoanalytic tripod. This article tells the historical origin of the model.
Those who look for training in psychoanalysis usually arrive with practical questions: how long it takes, how much it costs, whether the certificate is valid, whether a university degree is needed. These are legitimate questions. But there is another one that almost never comes up, and that changes the meaning of all the others: who decided that training a psychoanalyst requires exactly three things — theoretical study, personal analysis and supervision — and why did that decision come to be treated as if it were the very nature of psychoanalysis?
The so-called psychoanalytic tripod is usually presented as a given. It has, however, a date, an address and protagonists. It was born of choices made at congresses, committees and institutes between 1918 and 1925, in a specific context, by people with largely generous intentions. Knowing this history does not serve to demolish what it produced. It serves to give back to the student something that naturalization took away: the possibility of asking whether what is required of them is a condition of the craft or a condition of belonging to an institution.
Before the tripod: a psychoanalysis without a gatekeeper
Freud did not undergo a training analysis. There was no one to conduct it. His formation as an analyst went through clinical practice, reading and what he himself called self-analysis, carried out from 1897 onward on his own dreams and recorded in part in his letters to Wilhelm Fliess. The first psychoanalysts — physicians, but also educators, writers and curious people who attended the Wednesday meetings in Vienna — were trained by reading, discussing cases and, when possible, talking with Freud himself.
This does not mean that Freud disregarded the analysis of the analyst. In 1910, in The Future Prospects of Psycho-Analytic Therapy, he already stated that no analyst goes further than his own complexes and resistances permit. In 1912, in Recommendations to Physicians Practising Psycho-Analysis, he recommended that anyone who intends to analyze others first go through an analysis with someone experienced. The word matters: he recommended. What was at stake was a care for listening, not an administrative requirement.
The difference between the two things seems small, and it is not. A care is offered; a requirement is demanded. A care depends on the desire of the one who receives it; a requirement depends on whoever has the authority to declare it fulfilled. The history of the tripod is, to a large extent, the history of the passage from one register to the other.
Budapest, 1918: the analysis of the analyst becomes a requirement
The first formal step took place at the 5th Congress of the International Psychoanalytical Association (IPA), in Budapest, in September 1918. Hermann Nunberg proposed, with Freud's consent, that the training analysis become mandatory for anyone who wished to practice psychoanalysis. The proposal was not unanimous: Otto Rank and Viktor Tausk opposed it. Even so, the idea gained general approval in the following years.
The moment is worth noting. Europe was emerging from the First World War, psychoanalysis was beginning to attract public interest, and with the interest came practitioners without any study, who used the name of psychoanalysis without knowing what it was. The concern with quality was real. The problem was not in the diagnosis, but in the remedy chosen: entrusting the institution with the power to decide who was ready.
Berlin, 1920: a free clinic and a training school
On February 14, 1920, the Psychoanalytic Polyclinic opened its doors in Berlin, proposed by Max Eitingon and Ernst Simmel and financed largely by Eitingon himself, heir to a family of fur merchants. Karl Abraham, president of the local psychoanalytic society, completed the core group. The clinic charged according to the patient's income, and about two thirds of those seen were treated for free.
The free treatment answered an appeal by Freud himself, who at the Budapest congress, in 1918, had foreseen that one day society would open clinics where treatment would be free. But it also fulfilled other functions, and these must be looked at without romanticism. Among the declared purposes of the polyclinic was to spread psychoanalysis. And the patients who did not pay were precisely the cases seen by the candidates in training, under the supervision of a more experienced analyst. The clinic was, at the same time, a service to the population, a public showcase for a method seeking recognition and a source of patients for those who were learning. Historians still debate which of these functions weighed more: for some, the clinic was above all a laboratory where candidates found patients; for others, a true community care center.
It was around this clinic that the Berlin Institute was organized, with a program that combined three elements: the candidate's training analysis, theoretical seminars and the treatment of patients under supervision — the so-called control analysis, the origin of what is today called supervision. For the first time, the training of a psychoanalyst had a curriculum, a teaching committee, stages and criteria for progression. The tripod was born, in practice. The door of the clinic was open to those who could not pay; the door of training, as will be seen, was much narrower. It is in this design of training, and not in the clinic, that the elitism associated with Eitingon's name lies.
There is also a shadow over the origin of the money. The fortune that sustained the polyclinic came from the Eitingon family's fur business, which after the Russian Revolution obtained from the Soviet government the monopoly on the sale of Russian furs abroad. Decades later, suspicions arose that Max Eitingon had links to the Soviet secret police, stemming from a kidnapping case in Paris in 1937; a relative of his, Naum Eitingon, was in fact a Soviet agent. These suspicions were never proven. The historian Theodore Draper contested them, and the journalist Mary-Kay Wilmers, who reconstructed the family's history, ended her research more perplexed than convinced. They are recorded here as what they are: an open question about the interests that financed the institutionalization of psychoanalysis, not a conclusion.
Bad Homburg, 1925: from a local practice to an international standard
At the 9th IPA Congress, in Bad Homburg, in 1925, Eitingon proposed that the Berlin system become the international standard, under an International Training Commission. The proposal was approved, and Eitingon chaired this commission from 1925 until his death, in 1943. Institutes inspired by Berlin emerged in Vienna, London, Budapest, The Hague, Frankfurt, New York, Chicago and Paris.
Here lies the decisive shift. As long as control analysis and training analysis were the practices of one institute, they could be discussed, adapted, refused. When they became the standard of an international association, they came to define who belonged and who was left out. What in Berlin was a way of organizing teaching became, throughout the world, the boundary between the recognized psychoanalyst and everyone else.
The elitism the model produced
The charge of elitism, repeated by so many critics throughout the century, does not depend on guessing intentions. It rests on the mechanisms that the training model created. They are worth examining one by one, because it is in them that exclusion happens.
The first mechanism is selection. The institutional model created committees in charge of deciding who could be admitted as a candidate, assessing personality, motivation and background. Those who had the expected profile got in; those who did not, for reasons that were not always made explicit, were left out.
The second is hierarchy. Over time, the function of training analyst became a position, conferred on few and coveted by many. This position concentrated prestige, patients and political influence within the societies. An institution in which advancement depends on being appointed by those already at the top tends to reproduce the top itself.
The third mechanism is the most delicate, and perhaps the most serious from a psychoanalytic point of view. When personal analysis becomes a condition for approval, it ceases to be a space belonging only to the analysand. The person speaks to their analyst knowing — or fearing — that he takes part, directly or indirectly, in the assessment of their aptitude. The transference, which should be able to circulate freely, comes to include the institution. It is hard to associate freely before someone who also decides your professional future.
The fourth is time and cost. Taken together, high-frequency analysis for years, paid supervisions and prolonged seminars form a path that few can sustain. No one needed to decide to exclude those without income, free time or proximity to the major centers: the very architecture of training took care of that.
There is an irony in this history, and it deserves to be stated without exaggeration. A clinic that treated the poor of Berlin free of charge — and that offered them, among other things, candidates in training as analysts — helped create a training system that, as the decades passed, only a small portion of the population could get through. Psychoanalysis went on speaking of the subject in general; the training of those who practice it became increasingly particular.
The lay question and the American closure
The harshest point of this trajectory did not happen in Berlin, but in the United States. In the mid-1920s, Theodor Reik, a Viennese analyst who was not a physician, was prosecuted in Vienna for the illegal practice of medicine. In his defense — and in defense of psychoanalysis itself — Freud wrote The Question of Lay Analysis in 1926, and added a postscript in 1927. His position was clear: what qualifies someone to be an analyst is adequate analytic training, not a medical degree. Freud even feared that psychoanalysis would be swallowed by medicine and reduced to one psychiatric technique among others.
American analysts, led by figures such as Abraham Brill, thought otherwise. They saw psychoanalysis as a medical specialty and wanted to bar non-physicians. In 1938, the American Psychoanalytic Association began restricting training and membership to physicians. This rule only fell after, in 1985, four clinical psychologists went to court alleging undue restraint of competition, with the support of the American Psychological Association. The settlement that opened training to non-physicians was signed in 1988.
For fifty years, therefore, in the country that most spread psychoanalysis in the postwar period, it was practically reserved for those with a medical degree and psychiatric training. Freud, who spent his life defending the opposite, lost this battle in his lifetime. It was only won, in part, in the courts, half a century later.
The critiques from within
It would be comfortable to imagine that the objections to the model came only from outside, from people without training or resentful of the institutions. That was not the case. Some of the most severe critiques were made by analysts trained in the system itself, who knew its inner workings.
Sándor Ferenczi, in 1928, called the analysis of the analyst the "second fundamental rule" of psychoanalysis. He was, therefore, on the side of those who valued it. But, in the same text, The Elasticity of Psycho-Analytic Technique, he insisted that the conventions of analysis should not be treated as untouchable laws. Valuing the analysis of the analyst and refusing its transformation into dogma were not, for him, contradictory positions.
Michael Balint, who went through the Berlin system as a candidate, published On the Psycho-Analytic Training System in 1948, in the International Journal of Psychoanalysis. There he described the Berlin system as a defensive reaction to the years of little structure that preceded it, and broke the silence that had surrounded training analysis since the IPA made it a requirement.
Siegfried Bernfeld went further. In a 1952 text, published after his death, in 1962, in the Psychoanalytic Quarterly, he proposed dismantling the entire training system, which in his view had become bureaucratized to the point of losing the spirit and passion of the pioneers.
In 1967, Jacques Lacan, who had already broken with the IPA precisely because of training, stated the principle that "the psychoanalyst authorizes himself only by himself". Years later, he added: and by some others. The phrase is often read as a license for anything. It was not. It shifts authorization from the institutional stamp to the path of the one being trained — and to the recognition of peers, not of a position.
Perhaps the most revealing critique came from Otto Kernberg, in 1996, shortly before becoming president of the IPA itself. In a deliberately ironic article, Thirty Methods to Destroy the Creativity of Psychoanalytic Candidates, he listed institutional practices that stifle trainees: slow progression, reverent teaching of Freud's texts, control over every stage. When someone about to lead the institution writes such a text, it can no longer be said that the critique comes only from outside.
Freud himself, in 1937, in Analysis Terminable and Interminable, suggested that the analyst return to analysis periodically, perhaps every five years. It is easy to read this as yet another requirement. Read carefully, it is something else: an acknowledgment that no one leaves analysis finished, and that no institutional diploma guarantees what only continuous work on oneself can sustain.
What the tradition itself admits today
Since 2007, the IPA has officially recognized not one, but three training models: the Eitingon model, the French model and the Uruguayan model. They differ mainly in the organization and timing of personal analysis. In the French model, for example, analysis is understood as a preparatory stage, prior to training proper, in which one works through one's own desire to be an analyst.
The fact is simple and has consequences. If not even the association that institutionalized the tripod still maintains that there is a single correct way to train a psychoanalyst, the idea that there is a natural and mandatory path loses much of its force. What exists are choices — more or less well-founded, more or less consistent with what one intends to train.
And in Brazil?
In Brazil, psychoanalysis is not a profession regulated by federal law. There is no professional council nor any diploma required by law to practice it. The psychoanalyst appears in the Brazilian Classification of Occupations, under code 2515-50, included by Portaria nº 397 of the Ministry of Labor, from 2002. This classification, however, is an administrative record of existing occupations, not a regulation that establishes requirements.
This means that the tripod, in Brazil, is a rule of each institution, not a legal requirement. Schools that choose to make it mandatory make a legitimate choice within the tradition they adopt. Schools that make it optional make another choice, also legitimate, which needs to be sustained by rigor of another kind. What does not hold up is presenting one of these choices as if it were the law, or as if it were the only possible psychoanalysis.
For those who want to understand the basics of the subject before going on, this text can be read together with what the psychoanalytic tripod is.
Academia Enlevo's choice
At Academia Enlevo, theoretical study is mandatory, assessed and has a completion criterion. Personal analysis and supervision are optional: students decide whether, when and with whom they will do each of them, and are never penalized for not doing them. This choice does not arise from disregard for analysis. It arises from a wager that was at the beginning of psychoanalysis and that was lost along the way: that the training of an analyst should not depend on a gatekeeper.
To sustain this wager without giving up rigor, the training relies on the Método Alma Enlevo and on the pedagogical resources of Campus Enlevo. And it relies, above all, on something that the institutional model rarely granted its candidates: trust in the intellectual capacity of those who study. The student is not treated as someone who must be watched until proving they deserve to belong, but as someone capable of building their own path, with responsibility for it.
I often tell students that, when choosing a training program, the decisive question is not what you want from the school, but what the school wants from you. A school may want your time, your money, your dependence for many years. It may also want your autonomy — and organize everything so that you leave it able to walk without it.
What this history allows us to understand
The psychoanalytic tripod is not an arbitrary invention. It was born of real concerns about the quality of listening, but also of a strategy of expansion and institutional control, around a clinic that served at the same time as care, showcase and training ground. Once transformed into an international standard, it also came to fulfill another function: deciding who can be a psychoanalyst and, with that, who is left out. The most severe critiques of this transformation came from within the tradition itself, and the tradition itself, today, admits more than one model.
There is a limit that must be acknowledged. Freedom of path is not the absence of demands. A training program that made analysis and supervision optional and, at the same time, gave up serious and assessed study would not be restoring Freud's spirit; it would merely be trading one problem for another. Freedom only makes sense when it comes with responsibility — of the school, which must offer rigor, and of the student, who must take on their own path.
The question that remains, then, is not for or against the tripod. It is more uncomfortable and more useful: faced with each requirement that a training program presents to you, is it at the service of your listening — or of the permanence of the institution?
To see how this history translates into concrete training choices, read the comparison between the tripod and the Alma Enlevo Method.
If you want to get to know a training program built on this freedom, see Academia Enlevo's online clinical psychoanalysis course.

