Imagine someone who has just completed training in psychoanalysis. They studied with method, passed the assessments, and stayed up late discussing cases and Freud’s texts with colleagues. The day after the last class, they type a short question into a search engine: “does a psychoanalyst need a license?”. Right below, ads appear for membership cards, seals, registration numbers, associations with solemn names. The question seemed technical. Deep down, they wanted to know something else: who, in the end, is going to tell me that now I may?
The situation is hypothetical, but the movement is common, and not only among beginners. It reveals an understandable desire: that someone from outside take on part of the weight of sitting before another person and listening to them. A document on the wall, a number on the business card, a body to turn to if something goes wrong. In most professions that deal with suffering, this place exists and has a name. In Brazilian psychoanalysis, it does not exist in the same way. And the most quoted sentence on the subject, Lacan’s, according to which the analyst is authorized only by himself, is usually used to close the discussion when it should open it.
It is worth examining the three things calmly: what the law says, what institutions offer, and what Lacan actually wrote. The question about the stamp deserves more than a legal answer, and less than a mystical one.
Why So Many People Look for a Stamp
Let us begin without disdain for those who look for the membership card. Asking for an external authorization is a reasonable gesture in almost everything in adult life. No one drives without a license, no one signs a building plan without registration, no one prescribes medication without a degree and a council. In these professions, the license does important work: it transfers to a public body the minimum verification of competence. The patient does not need to check personally whether the doctor studied anatomy; the State did that for them.
There is, however, a second job that the license does, less openly declared. It relieves. Whoever holds a registration can lean on it on days of doubt: if the council recognizes me, then I am what I say I am. The external authorization works as a guarantor of professional identity. And psychoanalysis, for reasons we will see, is a practice in which doubt about one’s own place does not disappear with time. It changes form, but it accompanies the analyst.
That is why the search for the stamp is not merely market naivety. It usually comes loaded with guilt (“do I have the right?”) and with a request for recognition (“can someone confirm that I am capable?”). Both of these affects are legitimate. The problem begins when a piece of paper is expected to resolve what belongs to the order of training and responsibility, and when someone is willing to sell that paper as if it did.
What Brazilian Law Says, and What It Leaves Open
The facts, with the precision the subject demands.
In Brazil, psychoanalysis is not regulated as a profession by federal law. There is no federal council of psychoanalysis created by law, along the lines of the Federal Council of Psychology or the Federal Council of Medicine. Consequently, there is no mandatory professional registration to practice psychoanalysis, nor a public body that grants or revokes a psychoanalyst’s license.
The occupation appears in the Brazilian Classification of Occupations, the CBO, maintained by the Ministry of Labor, under code 2515-50. This fact is often misinterpreted. The CBO is a catalog that describes occupations existing in the labor market, used for statistics, employment records and registries. Being listed there means the occupation is recognized as a reality of the market; it does not mean it has been regulated, that it requires registration, or that anyone oversees its practice.
Psychology, for its part, has been a regulated profession since Law 4,119 of 1962, and the psychologist needs registration with the regional council of their region. They are distinct things: a psychologist can be a psychoanalyst, and a psychoanalyst may not be a psychologist. Whoever is not a psychologist cannot present themselves as one, and the same holds for the titles of any regulated profession. The doubt about prior university education is so frequent that it has a text of its own, on whether the psychoanalyst needs a university degree.
As for courses: the psychoanalysis training programs offered in the country are, as a rule, professional training courses. A professional training course is neither an undergraduate degree nor a postgraduate degree recognized by the MEC, and it does not depend on MEC authorization to operate. This does not make it clandestine; it makes it something else. The certificate of a professional training course attests that the person completed that path at that institution. It is not equivalent to a university diploma and confers no legal qualification, simply because there is no legal qualification to confer. Those who come to psychoanalysis without a university degree will find a more detailed explanation on the page about psychoanalysis training without a degree.
And what about registrations, membership cards, associations? They play a real role, and it is worth describing it without exaggeration in either direction. A registration linked to a training program proves that that path took place, allows third parties to verify it, and places the professional within a set of rules: a code of ethics, bodies for complaints, peers to whom to answer. The Academia Enlevo certificate, for example, is presented with registration in the RNTP. This gives the student and the patient something verifiable in a field where the State keeps no registry of its own. What no registration does, and no serious registration promises to do, is replace the study that should stand behind it. The target of the criticism, therefore, is the stamp sold with no training to support it, the membership card bought as a shortcut.
Hence a consequence less comfortable than it seems. The absence of regulation does not mean the absence of responsibility. The psychoanalyst answers, like anyone, for what they do: for what they promise, for what they charge, for the confidentiality they keep or violate, for the harm they cause. Only that they answer without the mediation of a council that would, first of all, judge conduct by the criteria of the practice itself.
What Lacan Wrote in 1967
It is into this void that Lacan’s sentence usually enters. It appears in the “Proposition of 9 October 1967 on the Psychoanalyst of the School”, a text in which he presented to the École Freudienne de Paris a new training device, the pass. The formulation, in English, is well known: “the psychoanalyst is authorized only by himself.”
The context matters. The sentence was not written against state regulation, a subject that was not the center of the text. Its target was the way the psychoanalytic institutions of the time produced analysts: by hierarchical appointment, with lists of training analysts qualified to train others, in a logic of co-optation that resembled that of a bureaucratic career more than that of an experience. Lacan distrusted a system in which someone became an analyst because a committee declared them fit, like someone moving up a level in a job-grade plan.
The verb matters too. In French, s’autoriser de means to rely on something as a source of authority, to invoke something as a guarantee. To say that the analyst is authorized only by himself is to say that, in the end, the source of the analytic act cannot be borrowed. No list, no title, no master can take the place of the one who, in a session, decides to intervene or to stay silent.
There are, however, two things that hasty quotations forget.
The first is in the 1967 text itself. Lacan did not abolish the institution. The same Proposition distinguishes authorization, which belongs to the analyst, from guarantee, which the School can give: the School can recognize that an analyst comes from its training. That is why the text organizes titles and procedures, among them that of Analyst Member of the School and that of Analyst of the School, the latter tied to the pass. In other words: in the same gesture in which he says that no one authorizes the analyst, Lacan sets up a device so that others can testify to what took place in someone’s training.
The second came later. In his 1973–1974 seminar, Lacan took up the formula again and added a complement to it: the analyst is authorized only by himself, “and by some others.” The addition does not contradict the original sentence; it situates it. Authorizing oneself does not happen in a vacuum. It happens among others: teachers who teach and assess, colleagues who read and disagree and, for those who choose them, an analyst and a supervisor. Lacan did not fix there a mandatory list of stages; he indicated that no one reaches the analytic act entirely alone.
Authorizing Oneself Is Not Granting Oneself a License
Read out of context, the formula becomes a safe-conduct: if only I authorize myself, no one can question me. It is a curious reading, because it inverts the meaning of the text. Where Lacan placed a weight, it places an exemption.
An image helps to see the mechanism. Think of notarization of a signature at a notary’s office. The notary confirms that the signature on the paper is yours. It does not answer for the content of what you signed, nor for the consequences of the contract. The signature remains an act of yours, with all its implications. The training institution works in a similar way: it can recognize that you went through a path, that you studied, that you were assessed, that you discussed cases. It cannot sign for you the act of sustaining a listening.
To authorize oneself, in this sense, is to accept that there will be no one to share the authorship of the act. When a patient says something never said to anyone, and the analyst must decide whether to punctuate, to wait, or to end the session, there is no council, membership card or school director present. There is a person who trained for that moment and who will answer for it. Lacan’s formula describes this solitude of the act. It does not authorize just anything; it takes from the analyst the alibi that someone told them to do it.
Seen this way, the “only” in the sentence is more demanding than any document. Whoever holds a registration may, on bad days, think they are doing what the body expects. Whoever is authorized by themselves has nowhere to hide. They need to know why they are there, what they desire from that position, and whether this desire is compatible with listening to another person or uses it for their own ends: to be admired, to feel needed, to exercise a power they lack elsewhere.
This point runs through the relation between guilt and autonomy in an interesting way. The guilt of the one who asks “do I have the right?” can be heard as a healthy scruple or as a request that someone say yes and take the matter off the table. The autonomy that psychoanalysis demands of the analyst does not eliminate this guilt by decree. It transforms it into a working question, one that is elaborated in study, in debate with colleagues and, for those who choose those paths, in one’s own analysis and in supervision, and not on a form.
What Institutions Offer, and What They Cannot Transfer
If the institution does not authorize, what is it for? The question is fair, and the answer does not diminish institutions. They do a great deal. They just do not do everything.
Freud already faced a version of this discussion in “The Question of Lay Analysis,” from 1926, written when a non-physician who practiced psychoanalysis was accused of the illegal practice of medicine in Vienna. Freud argued that what qualifies someone to analyze is psychoanalytic training, and not a medical degree in itself. His argument did not dispense with training; on the contrary, it shifted the requirement to where it made sense: knowledge of theory and technique, and not the credential of another profession.
It was in the psychoanalytic associations that the so-called tripod was consolidated: study, training analysis and supervision. It is an institutional tradition, formalized at the Berlin institute in the 1920s and adopted by the international association in 1925; it is not a legal requirement, nor the only path of training. Even so, it helps to see what a good institution can offer. It organizes theoretical transmission, with careful reading, sequence, assessment and correction of mistaken understandings. It creates spaces for debate and for discussing cases, where the student discovers that their listening has blind spots. It offers peers, that is, people who will disagree with them with arguments. It upholds a code of ethics and some place to which a complaint can be taken. And it lends a name that answers publicly for the training it gives.
What it cannot transfer is equally clear. The institution cannot study in the student’s place. It cannot give them a desire to be an analyst, nor guarantee that this desire has been interrogated. It cannot be in the room when the patient speaks. It can teach, assess, recommend, testify, but the passage from student to analyst takes place somewhere no certificate enters.
There is also a detail that usually goes unnoticed: training does not end with the certificate. In “Analysis Terminable and Interminable,” from 1937, Freud observed that clinical work stirs up what is unresolved in the one who listens, and that this is not settled once and for all. If the one who listens remains in elaboration, it would be strange for a piece of paper to close the question of authorization.
That is why, when choosing a training program, the most useful question is not “does it give me a membership card?” but “what does it demand of me and what does it offer me to sustain that demand?”. In the Clinical Psychoanalysis Training of Academia Enlevo, study is mandatory and assessed, while personal analysis and supervision are optional, because the training rests on the Método Alma Enlevo and on the resources of Campus Enlevo; the student decides whether, when and with whom to undertake them. The choice is coherent with the very idea of authorizing oneself: the institution demands what it is its place to demand and does not occupy the place of decision that belongs to the one being trained. For those who want to understand where the tradition comes from and what it proposes, there is a text on the psychoanalytic tripod.
The Symmetrical Risk: Self-Proclamation
So far, the target has been the fantasy that a stamp would resolve everything. But it would be dishonest to stop there, because the opposite error is equally frequent and, perhaps, more dangerous for patients.
A practice without a federal council and a formula that says “is authorized only by himself” form, together, fertile ground for self-proclamation. It is enough for someone to leaf through half a dozen books, watch scattered videos, collect certificates from courses with no assessment or real course hours, and announce sessions. From the legal point of view, there is no one to stop them from using the word psychoanalyst. And they can still quote Lacan to end any objection.
The irony is that this person uses Lacan’s sentence exactly like a membership card: an external document that would dispense with explanations. They do not authorize themselves; they are authorized by a quotation. The gesture is the same as that of someone who buys the stamp without study, only with the sign reversed. In one case, someone expects a piece of paper to guarantee what it cannot guarantee. In the other, someone expects a formula to dispense with what it cannot dispense with.
What the two movements have in common is the attempt to avoid the encounter with one’s own insufficiency. Whoever wants the stamp as a shortcut wants the other to fill the lack. Whoever self-proclaims wants the lack not to appear at all. In both cases, the work that training should do, which is to make the lack thinkable and bearable without turning it into a pose, is left out.
The addition “and by some others” is the most direct answer to this risk. Whoever has never had their study assessed by anyone, never completed a path with a criterion of completion, and does not accept discussing their practice with any interlocutor still has nothing to be authorized by, because they have not gone through what gives the formula its content. Lacan’s “himself” is not the ego that declares itself capable; it is something produced along the path, and that path includes others.
It would also be unfair to measure seriousness by the calendar. An intensive training of a few months can be rigorous, and one of many years can be slack. The criterion lies neither in duration nor in the number of diplomas, but in the rigor of what was studied and assessed and in the willingness to expose one’s own practice to the gaze of others. The weight of this decision to present oneself to the world with that name is treated more slowly in the weight of calling yourself a psychoanalyst.
Questions That Say More Than a Paper Alone
If there is no document that would dispense with thought, what remains for those who want to train and for those who look for an analyst? Questions remain. They take more work than checking a number, but they also inform much more, and go well with it.
For those seeking treatment, some are reasonable and can be asked without embarrassment:
- Where did this analyst train, and what did that training demand and assess?
- Does the training have a registration that a third party can verify?
- With whom do they discuss their own practice: colleagues, study groups, a supervisor, an analyst?
- Which code of ethics do they refer to, and to whom could a complaint be taken?
- Do they promise results, deadlines or cures? Whoever promises too much is usually answering to something other than the patient’s demand.
None of these answers guarantees, on its own, that the listening will be good. But the way the analyst answers already says something. An analyst who gets irritated at the question, or who settles it merely by displaying titles, reveals a relation to authority that deserves attention. One who explains calmly where they come from and to whom they answer is, in a way, practicing the “and by some others.”
For those in training, the questions change direction, but not nature. What brought me here? What do I hope to gain by occupying this position? Who follows my practice and can tell me, frankly, where I am going wrong? What kind of authorization am I still waiting to receive, and from whom? That last one tends to be the most revealing. Sometimes what someone looks for in the search engine is the substitute for a confirmation they would like to hear from another person, perhaps long before thinking about being an analyst.
A question about institutions is also worth asking, without cynicism. A school that sells the idea that its certificate “legally qualifies” one to practice is saying something that does not correspond to the Brazilian legal situation. A school that says clearly what it is, a professional training course, what it demands and what it offers, is treating the student as an adult. The difference between the two lies not in the paper they hand over, but in what they promise about it.
An Authorization That Does Not End
Let us return to the person at the beginning, facing the search engine. The question they typed has a short legal answer: in Brazil, there is no professional registration mandatory by law to practice psychoanalysis, there is no federal council, the CBO describes the occupation without regulating it, and the certificate of a free training attests a path, not a state license. Registrations and associations add verification and rules of conduct, which has value. That part is settled in a few lines.
The other question, the one underneath, is not settled that way. Who authorizes me? A careful reading of Lacan suggests that no one can answer in their place, and that, even so, they do not arrive at the answer alone. Authorization is built in study taken seriously and assessed, in debates, in mistakes acknowledged before colleagues and, for those who choose them, in one’s own analysis and in supervision. It is not granted one day and kept in a wallet. It is sustained, or not, each time someone sits down to listen.
There are limits to this analysis that should be admitted. The lack of regulation leaves the patient without a single public registry to consult, and that weighs; serious registrations and associations fill part of this gap, but they depend on someone seeking them out and knowing what to ask. It is also possible that, one day, the legislation will change. If it does, there will be a state registration to obtain, but the underlying question will remain where Lacan placed it: no body will be present at the moment of the act.
The implication, then, falls on the one who asks. Wanting a registration is not shameful, and dispensing with study by means of a quotation is not a sign of maturity. Taking either of the two as a substitute for training may be a way of not sustaining the question long enough. Perhaps the best measure that someone is becoming an analyst is precisely this: being able to carry the question “who authorizes me?” without demanding that it end, and without pretending that it never existed.

