Two suspicions circulate at the same time and rarely meet. The first says that analysis by video is not real analysis: a pleasant conversation with someone on the other side of a screen, perhaps useful, but without the density of the consulting room. The second almost never presents itself as a suspicion, because it comes dressed as reverence: the idea that analysis happens on the couch, in a silent room, with a bookshelf and an armchair behind the patient’s head. One distrusts the screen; the other trusts the furniture too much.
The two share an assumption worth examining. Both suppose that what makes an analysis work lies in the setting. For one, the digital setting is too poor; for the other, the classic setting is enough. If that were so, it would be enough to swap the camera for a couch to guarantee the work, and a couch would be enough for something analytic to happen. Anyone who has been through an analysis, or through a frustrated attempt at one, knows it is not that simple. There are impeccable consulting rooms where nothing moves for years, and there are improbable conversations that change a person’s position before their own life.
The question that matters, then, is not whether “online psychoanalysis works,” as if the answer could come in a seal of approval. It is another one: what sustains an analysis, and which parts of that whole the screen preserves, alters or threatens. It is worth answering calmly, because the hurried answer, in either direction, usually serves the one selling a conviction more than the one looking for treatment.
The couch was a technical solution, and Freud said why
Let us begin with the most symbolically loaded object. In “On Beginning the Treatment,” from 1913, Freud explains why he keeps the patient lying down while he himself sits behind, out of sight. The justification has two parts, and neither is mystical. The first is personal, almost confessional: he says, in substance, that he could not bear being stared at by other people for so many hours a day. The second is technical: by staying out of view, the analyst prevents his facial expressions from giving the patient material for interpretations, influences and responses, so that the transference can develop without being contaminated by the visible reactions of the one who listens. Freud also recalls that the arrangement is a historical remnant of the hypnotic method, from which psychoanalysis had emerged.
Notice what this means. The couch was not presented as a sacred place, but as a device for reducing an interference: the analyst’s face. It is a tool designed to solve a precise problem. Whoever turns this piece of furniture into an emblem of “true analysis” does with it what institutions usually do with their founding objects: forgets the function and keeps the fetish. The couch comes to prove something, and the question of what it did disappears.
This reading does not diminish the couch. On the contrary, it allows us to take it seriously. If the function was to remove the analyst’s face from the patient’s field and to favor speech less addressed to the approval of someone who is looking, the fair question about the online setting is whether that function can be fulfilled, and at what cost. Many analysts who work by video propose, when it makes sense, that the patient turn off the image, or lie down and use only the audio. Others keep the face-to-face, as was already done in many in-person sessions, especially in initial interviews or in cases where lying down is not advisable. There is no single rule. What exists is a technical problem that Freud himself formulated, and that remains standing when the room changes.
What actually sustains an analysis
If the furniture does not sustain it, what does? The list is no secret, but it is worth saying what each element does, rather than reciting it.
Transference. It is the phenomenon by which the patient updates, in the relationship with the analyst, old ways of loving, fearing, demanding and defending themselves. It is not a side effect of the treatment; it is the terrain on which the treatment takes place. Transference does not depend on breathing the same air in the same room. It appears wherever someone is supposed to know something about another’s suffering, and this can happen in a letter, in a phone call, in a video call. In fact, it appears even before the first session, in the choice of a name, in the fantasy about who this analyst will be.
Free association. The fundamental rule asks the patient to say whatever comes to mind, even what seems irrelevant, shameful or absurd. In the 1913 text, Freud uses a well-known image: the patient should behave like a traveler sitting by the window of a train, describing to someone inside the compartment the landscapes he sees passing by. The image is useful because it shows the mechanism: the rule does not demand depth, it demands not selecting. The obstacle to free association was never physical distance; it was censorship, the wish to appear coherent, the fear of judgment.
The analyst’s attention. In “Recommendations to Physicians Practising Psycho-Analysis,” from 1912, Freud describes evenly suspended, or floating, attention: the analyst should not fix on anything in advance, should not select what seems important to him, so as not to find only what he already expected. And he proposes a curious comparison for anyone discussing online analysis: the analyst should turn his own unconscious, like a receiving organ, toward the transmitting unconscious of the patient, adjusting himself to it as the telephone receiver is adjusted to the microphone that transmits. The metaphor is Freud’s, in 1912. The founder of psychoanalysis, to explain listening, resorted to a device for communicating at a distance. The image should not be forced to say more than it says, but it shows that, for him, the essential lay in transmission and reception, not in the furnishings.
Regularity. Fixed day and hour, agreed duration, sustained frequency. Freud speaks of renting an hour to the patient, who becomes responsible for it even when absent. Regularity creates a stable background against which variations mean something: the delay, the forgetting, the sudden wish to reschedule.
Payment. In the same 1913 text, Freud treats money without embarrassment. He observes that people handle money matters with the same hypocrisy as sexual ones, and that the analyst should speak of it frankly. Payment is not merely remuneration: it inscribes the treatment in an exchange, prevents it from becoming a favor, and often brings to the session the way the patient deals with debt, guilt and deservingness.
Confidentiality. Without the guarantee that what is said there does not leave there, no one associates freely. Confidentiality is an ethical condition and also a technical one.
The analyst’s desire. The expression comes from Lacan and does not designate a personal desire of the analyst for the patient. It designates the position of someone who sustains the analysis without wanting the patient’s good according to a model of their own, without wanting to be loved, without wanting to teach how to live. It is what keeps the session from becoming counseling. No camera produces or destroys this; whoever lacks it in the consulting room will not find it on the screen.
These elements, together, form what is called the frame. To think about what happens when it changes, one more step is worthwhile.
The frame only appears when it fails
The Argentine psychoanalyst José Bleger, in his 1967 text on the psychoanalysis of the psychoanalytic frame, drew attention to something that technique usually treats as background. The frame, he said, works as a non-process: it is the set of constants that allows the process to happen. And for that very reason it is mute. No one comments on the wall of the room while it is there. But, according to Bleger, it is in this silent background that the patient deposits very primitive aspects of themselves, ties that never come to be spoken. They reveal themselves only when the frame is broken.
This idea helps more than any defense of or attack on the online format. It suggests that the question is not only whether the virtual frame is “sufficient,” but which constants it offers and where it tends to fail. In the consulting room, the failure may be the analyst who changes rooms, goes on vacation, raises the fee. On the screen, the failure has another face: the image freezes in the middle of a difficult sentence, the sound lags, the connection drops exactly when the patient was about to say something they had been avoiding for weeks.
Here care is needed not to romanticize. A technical interruption is not automatically analytic material. Sometimes the internet simply went down. But the way the patient reacts to it, with relief, with anger, with guilt for having “disrupted” things, with the fantasy that the analyst gave up, often says something. And so does the way the analyst deals with it. A well-arranged online frame includes what to do when the call drops: who calls back, by what means, whether the lost time is made up. Agreeing on this beforehand is not bureaucracy; it is giving form to a background that would otherwise reveal itself only at the worst moment.
What really changes when the room becomes a screen
Maintaining that the essence of analysis is not in the furniture does not authorize saying that nothing changes. A great deal changes, and those who practice know it. It is worth naming the differences without drama and without minimization.
The body arrives cropped
In the consulting room, the analyst sees the patient come in, notices the step, the smell of rain on the coat, the hesitation when lying down, the way of getting up at the end. On the screen, he receives a rectangle, almost always from the chest up, mediated by a camera that flattens and a light that does not always help. Part of what the body communicates is lost. On the other hand, something appears that did not appear before: the face very close, sometimes closer than would be comfortable in a room, and the background of the patient’s home, which says things the patient has not said. This is not compensation; they are different pieces of information, with different risks. Interpreting the decor of the patient’s room would be as invasive as ignoring that it is there.
The silence of the image
In a consulting room, silence has texture. There is breathing, street noise, the body settling. In a video call, silence can look like a technical failure. Many patients, and many analysts, feel the impulse to ask “can you hear me?” after a few seconds without sound. That impulse deserves attention, because it presses toward filling the gap. Analysis needs pauses in which nothing is said and nothing breaks; the screen, by its app logic, pushes toward continuous speech. Part of the work, online, is to restore silence to its place, including by explicitly agreeing that it may happen.
The patient’s privacy at home
This is, perhaps, the most serious point. In the consulting room, the analyst guarantees a protected space. Online, the one who provides the space is the patient, and they cannot always do so. Imagine, hypothetically, someone who lives in a small apartment with family and can only speak from inside the car, in the garage; or someone who needs to speak precisely about a person who is in the next room. Free association meets a concrete limit here: one does not say everything when one fears being overheard. The analyst cannot solve this alone, but cannot pretend the problem does not exist. Sometimes the way out is adjusting the schedule; sometimes it is recognizing that, at that moment in life, in-person sessions or another arrangement would be more suitable.
The connection and the device
Whoever works by video depends on a network, a device, a platform. This includes ethical choices: using means that protect the content of the session, not recording without explicit consent (and, as a rule, not recording), taking care over where notes and messages are kept. Confidentiality, which in the consulting room depends on doors and walls, here depends also on settings that the analyst needs to know at least minimally.
The session “among other things”
And there is a less visible but decisive change. Going to the consulting room requires a journey: leaving home, crossing the city, waiting in the waiting room, returning. That trip, which seems a waste of time, works as a frame. It separates the session from the rest of the day. Online, the session may start one minute after a work meeting and end one minute before picking up the child from school. The temptation is to fit it in among other things, like one more open window. And not only for the patient: the analyst too may have email open in a corner of the screen, the phone buzzing beside him. The floating attention Freud spoke of does not survive notifications well.
The irony is discreet, but it is there: the technology that made analysis accessible to those who live far away is the same that threatens it through an excess of accessibility. A session that fits anywhere runs the risk of occupying no place at all.
Freud also worked at a distance, with limits he himself pointed out
It is often said that Freud “did analysis at a distance” in the case of Little Hans. The claim needs precision. In “Analysis of a Phobia in a Five-Year-Old Boy,” published in 1909, Freud reports the treatment of a boy afraid of horses. The one who carried out most of the work was the boy’s father, who knew Freud’s ideas, observed his son, talked with him and sent detailed reports. Freud guided the father on the basis of those reports and, according to the text itself, met the boy in person only once during the treatment.
The case is interesting for the current debate for two reasons, and neither is the naive idea that “Freud was already doing it online.” The first is that it shows that analytic work can take place through mediation: the material reached Freud in writing, filtered, and still he could formulate hypotheses and intervene. The second is that Freud was the first to point out the limits of the arrangement. He observes that the treatment was only possible because the authority of a father and that of a physician were united in one person, and acknowledges that this combination had effects of its own on what was said and what was heard. In other words, mediation is not neutral. It transmits, but it also distorts.
That is exactly the useful lesson for thinking about the screen. Every mediation does something to what passes through it. The telephone of 1912, the father of 1909, the camera of today. The question is not whether there is mediation, because even the consulting room has its own, but whether it can be included in the listening instead of ignored.
The pandemic did not invent online practice, it merely made it inevitable
Phone and video sessions already existed before 2020, surrounded by reservations. With the covid-19 pandemic, remote care ceased to be the exception and became, for a time, the only possible way to continue many treatments. Analysts who had never considered working by video found themselves obliged to do so, and patients who would never have chosen this route discovered that it was what there was.
There is no reason to inflate what this experience proved. It did not, by itself, produce a demonstration of equivalence between in-person and online. What it did was shift the debate from the field of hypothesis to the field of practice. Many treatments continued; some were interrupted; others began then and never knew another form. From this point on, it became harder to maintain that analysis by video “does not exist,” and also harder to maintain that it is identical to in-person analysis. What we have is a practice with its own conditions, which demands the same rigor required of the consulting room, and sometimes more.
One more observation the pandemic made clear: for those who live far from major centers, for those with reduced mobility, for those who live abroad and want to be heard in their own language, online is not an impoverished version of treatment. Often it is the only version available. Treating this as “second-class analysis” is a form of elitism that presents itself as technical rigor.
At the same time, there are situations in which online work calls for special caution. When there is risk to life, an intense crisis or a need for a nearby care network, physical distance can be a real problem, and the analyst needs to know how to call for local help. If you are going through intense suffering right now, seek a mental health professional; in Brazil, the CVV offers free support by phone at 188, at any hour.
Online therapy, online analysis: the distinction that matters
Whoever searches for “online therapy” finds everything: apps with short sessions, care by message, structured programs, psychotherapies of different schools and psychoanalysis. It is not for us to rank these practices here; many have value of their own. But it is best not to confuse them, because the question “does it work?” depends on what one expects.
If the expectation is to receive clear guidance, goals and techniques for dealing with a specific symptom, there are approaches designed for that, and they can adapt well to the digital format. Analysis proposes something else. It does not promise to eliminate the symptom by a shortcut; it proposes that the patient listen to what they say, find the repetitions in which they are stuck, and reposition their relation to their own desire. This takes time, demands regularity and implies the patient’s responsibility for their own speech. The online format does not alter this proposal. It alters the conditions under which it is sustained.
Hence a practical consequence for those who are searching: more important than asking whether the professional works online is asking how they understand the work they do. How often are the sessions? How do they handle absences and payment? What is their training, their personal analysis, their supervision? These questions apply to the consulting room and to the screen. An analyst who cannot answer them in person will not be able to answer them virtually.
And training: what is learned online and where practice comes in
The debate about online analysis has a close sibling, the debate about online training. And it tends to repeat the same mistake as at the start: supposing that seriousness lies in the setting. As if a physical classroom, by itself, guaranteed a better-prepared analyst, and a video class produced a second-rate analyst.
Psychoanalytic theory is learned by reading, discussing, listening to those who have read more, being contradicted, being assessed. This happens very well in a digital environment, with live classes, discussion groups and case study. The reading of Freud does not become shallower because the seminar takes place by video; it becomes shallower when no one reads the text. The criterion of seriousness of a training is not the medium or the length, but rigor: effective study, real course hours, assessment, a clear criterion for completion. At Academia Enlevo, the online clinical psychoanalysis training is entirely remote, with 720 hours in 24 modules, live classes every two weeks, discussion groups and case analysis. Online is not a concession there; it is the model.
Some maintain that an analyst’s training is only complete within a mandatory tripod of study, training analysis and supervision. This arrangement is a respectable tradition, consolidated by psychoanalytic associations from the 1920s onward, but it is an institutional tradition, not a legal requirement nor the only possible path. Turning it into a password for entry, to the point of saying who is and who is not a “real psychoanalyst,” is precisely the kind of ready-made formula that psychoanalysis itself teaches us to distrust. Lacan formulated that the analyst authorizes himself only from himself, and added: not without some others. Authorization is not an institution’s stamp; it is a position that each one sustains and answers for.
This does not diminish the value of personal analysis and supervision; it changes their place. They are recommended and precious experiences. In personal analysis, those who will listen to others experience in their own speech the transference, the resistance, the fundamental rule. In supervision, someone with more experience accompanies the first sessions, helps perceive what escaped, points out where the analyst’s desire was mistaken for a wish to help, to please, to be right. But it makes a difference that they be chosen, not imposed: the student decides when and with whom, and that decision already says something about how they implicate themselves in their own path. This is how Enlevo treats both: as optional, because the training rests on the Método Alma Enlevo and on the resources of the Campus Enlevo. On the role and forms of clinical supervision in training, there is a more detailed discussion in another text.
There is also a dimension that concerns the very theme of this essay. Whoever is going to practice online needs to have thought through the online frame: how to arrange the schedule, what to do when the connection drops, how to deal with the patient’s privacy, when in-person sessions would be preferable. Part of this is discussed in class and in case analysis; part is only learned by practicing, and supervision, when the analyst seeks it, is a good place to think through these situations with someone who has already faced them. The question of whether it is possible to prepare for clinical practice by studying psychoanalysis online has an answer similar to this text’s: it depends less on the medium and more on what is demanded within it.
It is also worth recalling, to avoid confusion, that in Brazil psychoanalysis is not regulated by a professional council, does not require a university degree, and that psychoanalysis training courses are open courses, not undergraduate or graduate degrees recognized by the MEC. This does not diminish the seriousness one can demand of a training; it only shifts the responsibility. In the absence of a body that supervises, it falls to the analyst, and to whoever trains them, to sustain rigor.
What the screen reveals about the consulting room
Let us return to the two suspicions at the start. The one that said analysis by video is not real analysis was right about one thing: the online format changes the conditions of the work, and changing the conditions is no detail. The body arrives cropped, silence becomes harder to sustain, privacy depends on someone who cannot always guarantee it, and the session runs the risk of becoming one more open window among so many. Whoever practices or undergoes analysis by video without taking this into account is, in fact, impoverishing the work.
The one that idealized the couch was also right about something: it solved a real problem, and the problem does not disappear because the room has changed. But it was wrong to suppose that the furniture guarantees the analysis. What Freud left us, in the texts of 1912 and 1913, was not a description of furnishings. It was a set of reasons: why the analyst leaves the field of vision, why the hour is rented, why money is discussed, why attention should float, why the patient should say everything. These reasons can be honored or betrayed anywhere.
Perhaps the most interesting contribution of the online format is precisely this: by taking the consulting room off the stage, it forces us to ask what the consulting room did. Bleger said that the frame only appears when it is broken. The passage to the screen was a rupture of this kind, on a large scale, and it brought into view something that had been concealed by the familiarity of the room.
A limit remains that should not be erased. There is not, as far as can be stated with confidence, a general answer about whether online analysis “works” as well as in-person analysis, and be wary of anyone who offers one ready-made. There are cases in which the screen helps, because it relieves the shame of being seen or makes possible a treatment that would not otherwise happen. There are cases in which it gets in the way, because the patient has nowhere to speak or because distance weighs heavily in a moment of crisis. The decision about format belongs to each analysis and must be open to revision within it.
For those looking for an analysis, the useful question is not “online or in person?”, but whether that space, whichever it is, allows one to say what has not yet been said. For those who intend to become analysts, the question is more uncomfortable: if you took away the couch, the room and the bookshelf, what would be left of your work? That is what the patient finds on the other side of the screen.
