Skip to content
enlevoACADEMY
Student space ↗0
Journal/Psychoanalysis
JOURNAL / ENLEVO

Parents Who Cannot Frustrate: The Child as a Project

20 / ENLEVOunderstanding.
Quick answer

Saying no to a child is hard when the child's happiness starts to work as proof of the parents' worth. Freud showed that parents relive their own narcissism in the child; Winnicott, that good-enough care includes failing gradually and surviving the child's anger without retaliating or falling apart. A limit sustained with affection, without humiliation or violence, is part of care.

Imagine a hypothetical scene, the kind anyone has witnessed in a supermarket checkout line. A child of four or five asks for a chocolate bar. The father says no, dinner is almost ready. The child insists, then cries, then throws himself on the floor. Two people look on. The father holds on to his no for some forty seconds, feels his face grow hot, remembers that he spent the entire week getting home after his son was already asleep, and takes the chocolate from the shelf. The child stops crying at once. The father breathes a sigh of relief.

It would be easy to turn this scene into a sermon about permissive parents. That is not what interests me. What interests me is a more uncomfortable question: in those forty seconds, who was suffering unbearably? The child was certainly frustrated. But a child's frustration passes, and passes quickly, when there is someone nearby able to bear it. What might not have passed so quickly was something on the adult's side: the guilt over the absent week, the gaze of strangers working as a tribunal, the suspicion of being a bad father. The chocolate, in this case, calmed two people. And the second of them was not five years old.

The thesis I want to examine is this: there is a kind of love that avoids all frustration for the child and that, beneath its apparent generosity, often protects the adult himself — from guilt, from the lack of love he imagines receiving if he says no, from the threat to the image he has built of himself as a father or mother. And this love, without anyone noticing, transfers a heavy burden to the child: to be the project that justifies the parents. To think this through, I will turn to two authors who said different and complementary things on the subject, Freud and Winnicott. But first we must be fair to the people standing in the supermarket line.

The context in which these parents are raising children

No father or mother invented the difficulty of frustrating a child all on their own. It has very concrete social conditions, and ignoring them would be armchair criticism.

The first is work. Many families live a routine in which the adults leave early, come home late and spend the weekend trying to make up for the absence of the weekdays. In this arrangement, the little time together takes on a disproportionate weight: it has to be good, it has to be light, it has to make up for the other days. A conflict on Saturday morning feels like a waste of the little there is. Saying no, at such moments, sounds almost like aggravating a debt the adult already feels he owes his child.

The second is exposure. Parenting has come to happen in front of an audience as well, real or imagined. Social networks display families that seem to solve everything with calm conversation, children who accept limits with an understanding smile, tidy bedrooms and impeccable lunchboxes. Anyone who compares their own home, on an ordinary day, with this edited cut tends to conclude that they are doing everything wrong. And the child's crying in public becomes public proof of that failure.

The third reason is perhaps the most respectable of all: many of today's adults grew up in harsh homes. They were beaten, humiliated, told that crying was whining and that a child had no say. Deciding not to repeat this is an ethical achievement, not a whim. The problem begins when the refusal of violence extends, without the person noticing, to every form of contradiction. As if every no carried within it the shadow of the belt, the shouting or the dark room. The pendulum, which had been stuck at one extreme, swings to the other, and the adult starts treating the child's frustration as if it were the same thing as the suffering he himself went through.

For this reason it is worth fixing a distinction right now, and keeping it to the end: frustrating a child is not humiliating or punishing the child with violence. Nothing that follows justifies hitting, shouting to terrorize, ridiculing or threatening abandonment. In Brazil, in fact, Law 13.010/2014, known as the Menino Bernardo Law, amended the Child and Adolescent Statute to affirm the child's right to be raised without physical punishment or cruel or degrading treatment. What is under discussion here is something else: an adult's capacity to say no, to sustain that no in the face of the child's displeasure and to stay there, whole, without striking back and without falling apart.

His Majesty the Baby: the parents' narcissism relived in the child

In 1914, in a text that is usually read for other reasons, Freud wrote a few lines about parental love that continue to disturb. In On Narcissism: An Introduction, he observes that parents' tenderness toward their children, when examined closely, reveals much of the narcissism the parents themselves had to abandon over the course of their lives. Faced with the child, that narcissism is reborn. Parents tend to attribute every perfection to the child, to forget the child's defects and to wish that the child be exempt from the renunciations they themselves had to make: that the laws of nature and of society be, in some way, suspended for the child. It is in this context that the famous expression appears, “His Majesty the Baby.”

Freud goes further. He says, in substance, that the child must fulfill the dreams the parents never fulfilled: become the great man in place of the father, marry a prince as compensation for the mother. The tone of the text has a touch of irony, and it is worth noting that Freud is not condemning the parents. He is describing a common, almost inevitable mechanism that is part of the way a child is invested with affection. Without some degree of this idealization, by the way, no baby would be cared for with the dedication that care demands.

The point that matters for our problem is a different one. If the child carries the parents' relived narcissism, the child's happiness ceases to be only the child's. It comes to function as a certificate: that the parents are good, that the choice to have children was worth it, that the hard childhood they had was finally repaired, that the absence during the week left no marks. When the child is content, the adult recognizes himself in a favorable mirror. When the child cries, the mirror darkens.

This is where the no becomes unbearable. Saying no to a child implies accepting, for a few minutes or a few hours, that the child will be angry with you, will not like you at that moment, that the mirror will return a less flattering image. For someone who needs the child's contentment as proof of his own worth, this interval is experienced as lack of love. It is not the child who cannot bear the no. It is the adult who cannot bear what the no produces in him.

A caveat is in order, so as not to fall into caricature. Not every parent who gives in is enslaved by his own narcissism. Sometimes giving in is the sensible decision: the request was reasonable, the no had been automatic, the child was exhausted. The same gesture can serve very different functions in different families. What Freud helps us see is a possibility, not a diagnosis of every parent who hands over the chocolate.

The failure that Winnicott considered necessary

If Freud shows where the investment that turns the child into a project comes from, Winnicott helps us understand why the absence of frustration is not a gift. And he does so without any taste for severity, which makes the argument even more interesting.

The expression “good-enough mother,” which he developed in the text on transitional objects and phenomena, later collected in Playing and Reality (1971), is often quoted as a consolation: nobody has to be perfect. That is true, but it is only half of the idea. The other half is more demanding. Winnicott describes how, at the beginning of life, whoever takes care of the baby adapts almost completely to the baby's needs. And then, little by little, this adaptation becomes less complete, to a degree that keeps pace with the baby's growing capacity to deal with this failure. Good-enough care therefore includes failing. Failing in the right dose, at the right time, gradually.

Why does this matter? Because a perfect and continuous adaptation would be, for the baby, indistinguishable from magic. If the breast, the bottle, the lap or the desired object appear exactly when they are wanted, always, the child has no way of discovering that there is a world outside, with its own rhythm, which does not obey his thinking. It is in the small wait, the small mismatch, that reality begins to present itself. The gradual failure of the environment is what allows the child to build, little by little, the notion that the other truly exists, separate from him.

A note on the word “mother”: Winnicott wrote in his own time, but what he describes is a function of care, and it can be exercised by a father, a grandmother, another caregiver. What holds for the good-enough mother holds for any adult who occupies that place.

In his texts on the facilitating environment, collected in The Maturational Processes and the Facilitating Environment (1965), Winnicott insists that emotional development depends on an environment that holds the child. To facilitate, in his vocabulary, does not mean to remove every obstacle. It means to offer conditions for the child to grow from his own potential, which includes encountering a world that resists, that says wait, that says not now. An environment that removes all friction does not facilitate maturation. It merely postpones it.

There is an irony in all this. Many parents who avoid frustrating rely, in good faith, on popular versions of Winnicott, as if he had defended an always available, always understanding, always attuned presence. The Winnicott of the texts is another one: someone who recognized in the caregiver's failure, provided it is bearable and accompanied, one of the engines of growth.

Striking back or falling apart: two ways of not surviving the child

Still in Playing and Reality, in a chapter on the use of an object, Winnicott proposes an idea that illuminates the question of limits very well. Simplifying without betraying: for the child to be able to recognize the other as someone real, separate from himself, that other must survive the attacks the child directs at him. To survive, here, means two things at once: not being destroyed and not retaliating.

Think about what happens when a child receives a no and explodes with rage. He says he hates his father, that his mother is the worst in the world, kicks the bedroom door. Faced with this, the adult has basically three paths. He can retaliate: shout louder, humiliate, hit, threaten to disappear. He can fall apart: go back on his word, apologize for the no, cry along, offer anything to make the anger stop. Or he can survive: hold the limit, stay present, not return the aggression and not come undone in front of it.

The first two paths seem opposite, and from the moral point of view they really are very different. Retaliating with violence causes harm that giving in does not cause. But, from the point of view of what the child learns about the other, they have something in common. In both cases, the child's anger had a devastating effect. In the first, it provoked a dangerous adult. In the second, it dissolved the adult. In neither does the child discover that he can feel anger toward someone he loves without that person being destroyed or becoming a threat.

This discovery has enormous value. A child who learns that the other survives his hatred can, little by little, hate and love the same person, tolerate ambivalence, make reparation after a conflict. A child who never meets this surviving other is left between two bad lessons: either the world punishes desire with violence, or the world bends to it. Neither prepares him for life with other people, who neither hit us at every contradiction nor hand us everything we ask for.

It is within this frame that the plea for help “my child won't accept no” gains another possible reading. Sometimes the child does not accept the no because, in his experience, the no never really was a no. It was a provisional position of the adult, who tended to give in when the insistence was strong enough. The child, in this case, is not being irrational. He is applying quite logically what he has learned: that the limit is negotiable in proportion to the scene he makes.

I say “sometimes” carefully. A child who reacts intensely to limits may be tired, hungry, going through an expected phase of development, or living through something that is not solved by a change in the parents' attitude. When the difficulty is persistent, intense or accompanied by other signs of distress, the conversation needs to go to a health professional who can assess that child, in that family. No blog text replaces this, and no theory authorizes labeling a child on the basis of a single scene.

The weight of being the project that justifies the parents

I return to the initial thesis, now with more elements. The love that does not frustrate is usually described as an excess of care. I propose to look at it also for what it asks in return.

When the child's happiness becomes proof of the parents' worth, the child receives, along with protection, a task. He must be well. He must be content, because his discontent hurts those he loves. He must succeed, because his success is what redeems the parents' story. Nobody says this out loud, and it is precisely because it is not said that the burden weighs. The child perceives, with the sensitivity children have for the emotional state of adults, that his sadness is not received as his sadness, but as an accusation against the parents.

A hypothetical situation helps to see the mechanism. A nine-year-old girl comes home from school upset because she was not chosen for a part in the end-of-year play. The mother, distressed, phones the school coordinator, questions the criteria, promises her daughter private acting lessons and, at night, comments on the injustice with the father in front of her. All out of love. But what can the girl conclude? Perhaps that her disappointment was too serious to be lived through, to the point of mobilizing the whole household. Perhaps that she had no time to be sad, because the sadness was immediately turned into a problem to solve. Perhaps, further, that her frustration had hurt her mother more than herself, and that next time it is better not to tell.

This last development is the most delicate. Children of parents who cannot bear to frustrate them sometimes learn to protect their parents from their own frustration. They hide low grades, downplay fights with friends, pretend everything is fine. Not out of lying in the moral sense, but out of a kind of inverted care: the child begins to manage the adults' mood. It is an inversion of places that tends to go unnoticed, because the surface is one of harmony.

There is also a later consequence. Someone who grew up without meeting limits sustained with affection tends to reach adult life with little experience of losing, waiting, hearing no without collapsing. The first boss who turns down a proposal, the first beloved person who leaves, the first failing grade, all these encounters with reality can be lived as catastrophe, because there was never a rehearsal. I am not saying this always happens, nor that it is the only origin of these difficulties. I am saying that the friction avoided in childhood does not disappear. It merely changes date.

How to say no to your child without turning the no into punishment

It would be incoherent, after criticizing formulas, to end with a list of infallible techniques. But some general guidelines follow from what has been said, and they may be useful to those who sincerely seek to understand how to set limits in childhood without repeating the harshness they lived through.

  • Ask whom the yes protects. Before giving in, a second of honesty is worthwhile: am I saying yes because the request is reasonable or because I cannot bear what I will feel if I say no? The question does not demand a perfect answer. It demands that the adult include himself in the scene.
  • Separate the limit from the feeling. It is possible to hold the limit and welcome the frustration at the same time. Something like: I understand you are angry, it makes sense to be angry, and the answer is still no. Welcoming does not revoke the limit, and the limit does not require the feeling to be silenced.
  • Say fewer nos, and sustain them. A no said by reflex and withdrawn after ten minutes of crying teaches more than ten firm nos. It is better to choose the limits that truly matter and keep them than to scatter prohibitions that nobody intends to enforce.
  • Do not add humiliation. The limit is about the behavior or the request, not about the child's worth. Phrases that ridicule, compare with siblings or threaten abandonment do not strengthen the no. They turn a limit into an unnecessary wound and teach that conflict is dangerous.
  • Repair when you get it wrong. Every adult sometimes shouts, exaggerates, says no out of tiredness. Acknowledging this afterwards, without collapsing into guilt, shows the child that relationships survive failures. It is, at bottom, Winnicott's gradual failure lived on a domestic scale.

None of these guidelines works as a recipe, because the difficult part was never knowing what to say. Plenty of people know perfectly well, in theory, how to say no to their child. The difficult part is bearing the minutes that follow: the scowl, the crying, the sentence “you don't love me,” the stranger's gaze in the line. And this is not learned from a tutorial. It depends on how much the adult can tolerate, within himself, the image of someone who, for a moment, is not being loved.

When the question returns to the adult

This is the point at which the discussion about limits stops being pedagogical and becomes clinical. If the obstacle to saying no lies on the adult's side, the useful question is perhaps not “what do I do with my child?” but “what in me cannot bear his displeasure?”.

The answers vary greatly. For one person, the child's no reopens the memory of a father who only knew how to shout, and any firmness seems like repetition. For another, the child's anger reproduces the coldness of a mother who withdrew affection as a form of punishment, and the adult does everything never to be the target of that ice. For a third, the child is the only area of life that seems to be going well, and each of his frustrations threatens this last territory of recognition. In all these cases, the difficulty with the limit is a symptom of a history, and a history is not solved with a behavior tip.

Psychoanalysis with children knows this movement well. Frequently, the work also involves the parents, because the complaint brought about the child carries questions that concern the adults. Those interested in this clinical practice find in it a field of its own, with its technical questions, as the path of a specialization in child psychoanalysis shows. And those who wonder about their own place, as mother, father or future professional, can begin by understanding what a psychoanalyst does and how this profession works in Brazil.

At Academia Enlevo, the training in clinical psychoanalysis has study as its axis and recommends personal analysis and supervision, which the student chooses when and with whom to undertake. The reason for recommending them has to do with the theme of this text: those who listen to families are also affected by what they hear. Faced with a child's anger or a father's distress, the professional may feel the same impulse as the parents he sees, to give in in order to be loved or to harden in order not to be hit, and having a space to think about this helps avoid acting on autopilot.

It is also worth remembering that not every family difficulty needs analysis. Often, a frank conversation between the adults of the house, a support network that eases the overload or simply a few more hours of sleep change the picture. But when the same impasse keeps returning, with different children, at different ages, perhaps the repetition is saying something that deserves to be listened to for longer, with a qualified professional.

What the no, in the end, protects

Let us return to the supermarket line. The father who took the chocolate is not a villain, and the child who threw himself on the floor is not a clinical case. The scene serves only to show how a small gesture can carry a large emotional economy. The chocolate settled the crying and settled, for a few minutes, the father's guilt. What it did not settle was the underlying question: what happens to a child when each of his frustrations must be immediately eliminated so that the adult can go on feeling good?

With Freud, it was possible to see that the parents' investment in the child carries the narcissism they themselves had to abandon, and that this turns the child, without anyone deciding it, into a showcase and a reparation. With Winnicott, it was possible to see that good-enough care includes failing little by little, and that the adult must survive the child's anger without striking back and without falling apart. Together, the two readings suggest that the no sustained with affection is a form of care, perhaps one of the most laborious.

The limits of this analysis need to be clear. It does not replace knowledge of a concrete family, with its material conditions, its histories and its particular impasses. It does not authorize diagnosing children from tantrums or parents from chocolates. And it does not pretend to ignore that many adults say yes because they are exhausted, alone, without a support network, and not because they are trapped in the narcissistic mirror. There is also a legitimate objection: in a culture that for a long time treated children's obedience as the supreme virtue, the fear of frustrating was, in part, a necessary correction. It is not a matter of going back, but of not confusing the abandonment of violence with the abandonment of the limit.

What remains, then, is a responsibility that does not fit into a rule. Each time an adult is about to say yes in order to end a conflict, he can ask himself whom that yes is serving. The answer will not always be comfortable. But perhaps it is through it that we begin to give back to the child the right to be only a child, with his desires, his angers and his disappointments, and not the living proof that his parents got it right.

Psychoanalysis training at Academia Enlevo, in facts
Course load
720 hours in 24 modules (Método Alma Enlevo)
Duration
6 to 24 months: 6 with prior background, 8 to 9 when starting from scratch
Format
100% online; recorded video lessons and reading material, in Portuguese
Completion
final assessments and a final paper
Certificate
recognized by the RNTP (Brazil), with ID card and registration number
Requirements
18 years old (or 16 with authorization); no degree required
Analysis and supervision
optional, supported by the Método Alma Enlevo and the Campus Enlevo resources
Type
professional training course in psychoanalysis; no degree required

See the Online Clinical Psychoanalysis Course

Ulisses Jadanhi
About the authorUlisses JadanhiMaster in Psychoanalysis, Máster en Psicología Criminal (Universidad Europea del Atlántico), PhD candidate in Mental Health

Prof. Ulisses Jadanhi is a psychoanalyst, educator and creator of projects focused on human development, therapeutic listening and the development of mental health. At the head of Academia Enlevo, he works on building training paths in psychoanalysis, philosophy, self-knowledge and clinical practice, with an approach that combines theoretical depth, ethical sensitivity and a commitment to transforming lives.

JOURNAL

One question leads
to another.

ENLEVO ACADEMY

Your next question
can start here.